A Longtime Rental Studio Gets A Prewar Restoration

When Emily moved to New York City last year, she went in search of an apartment with a warm, old-world feel. Although originally from California, she had recently spent two years living and studying in Normandy, France, where she developed an appreciation for beautiful prewar buildings that wore their age gracefully. Emily loved that the apartments she came across there—no matter how small or simple—always had ornamental features that elevated the space. Paneling, vintage doorknobs, and other small details contributed to an overall elegance, and she wanted the same for her new apartment in New York.


A six month-long search resulted in the purchase of a 435-square-foot studio apartment in an understated 1940s building on the Upper West Side. It was a prewar apartment but also a condo, a rare combination that suited Emily’s criteria. Although it was a studio, it had distinctly separate spaces: an entryway, dressing area, kitchen, bath, and main living space, which Emily liked. Unfortunately, having been used as a longtime rental property, the apartment had been stripped of most of its original ornamentation. Instead, there was paint a dozen layers thick and worn flooring throughout the studio. In the narrow galley kitchen, there were sticky off-white cabinets, peeling vinyl floors, and almost no counter space at all. The very peachy-yellow bathroom sported tiles that didn’t match in spots where they had once been replaced, and a tank-less, industrial toilet gave the small space an unpleasantly institutional vibe. To the left of the front door, two shallow closets took up valuable floor space, which Emily felt would be better utilized as an office nook.

SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-Before-During-02 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-Before-During-01

Emily envisioned a restoration of sorts: she wanted to add paneling and crown molding to the walls of the main living space, and to create a simple bath with a vintage black-and-white theme. The kitchen would be modern but befitting the age of the building. And although the discrete spaces of the apartment were a major selling point, Emily felt that the narrow kitchen would be much improved if it could be opened up to the main living area. Pinterest provided ample inspiration, and she set out to source the materials herself, relying heavily on Wayfair and other online stores.

Having developed a concrete plan for the renovation, Emily and her dad, John, posted the project to Sweeten. John had had substantial experience with construction and renovation in the past, and with his input, Emily settled on Sweeten Expert Nicky. Nicky quickly went to work realizing Emily’s vision, and also provided helpful suggestions and additions along the way. For example, unprompted, Nicky stripped a half-century of paint from the front door, revealing the beautiful metal patina underneath.

Based on Emily’s direction, Nicky created a pass-through from the galley kitchen to the living area, extending the counter through the opening to create a breakfast perch with stools. Open shelving made of marble and brass took the place of upper cabinets, creating more room to breathe in the narrow space. The appliances and sink were lined up on the left, given that the counters and base cabinets on the right were a mere nine inches deep. (The entire kitchen was just about six feet wide!) An under-counter refrigerator, paneled to blend in with the cabinets, preserved the new airiness of the space. Sadly, there was no room for a dishwasher, but a 24-inch Bertazzoni gas range fit perfectly at the end of the counter. Finishes were consistent with those found in older buildings, featuring white subway tile, marble counters, brass detailing, charcoal gray lower cabinets, and blackened metal light fixtures with a retro feel. For the floor, Emily chose a fun Spanish tile in black and white.

SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-06 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-09 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-10 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-11

In the original dressing area, the floor space was expanded once the closets were removed. Custom shelving and a desk were cut to fit inside the nook perfectly, creating a cozy home office away from the main sleeping area. In the main room of the studio, Nicky added small details that restored elegance to the apartment. Marble ledges on the windows, as well as wall paneling, crown molding, and new baseboards transformed the space in subtle but distinct ways. The bathroom received a similarly unpretentious and classic treatment: white subway tile with a beveled edge and black trim, matched to a matte black towel rack. To prevent an accidental burn and to disguise an unsightly floor-to-ceiling radiator pipe, Nicky suggested that they wrap it with rope.

SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-05 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-01 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-02 SWEETEN_John_Kitchen_Bathroon-03

Interestingly, unlike many of Sweeten’s renovating homeowners, Emily and John managed the project from afar—they were in California while Nicky and his team worked on her apartment. They arranged for check-ins via FaceTime or Skype, and Nicky provided photos and updates on the work on a regular basis. Despite the 2,500 miles between them, there were remarkably few hiccups on this Sweeten project. Emily and John attributed this to good communication with Nicky and his team, but also to the fact that they went into the process with a firm plan, and sourced the materials for arrival prior to the start of the job. Emily’s advice to future renovators: “There is a lot that can go wrong when you’re renovating, but it helps to start with a good idea of what you want. And if you source the materials yourself, you can cut down on some of the variables that might delay the project.”

Thanks so much, Emily, and we hope you’re enjoying your lovely new-old studio!

Kitchen selects >> floors: Express Brooklyn Tile / cabinets: Hanssem: Charcoal Gray Somerset  / cabinet pulls: Cynthia Rowley / cabinet knobs: Anthropologie / refrigerator: U-Line: 24-inch undercounter  / range: Bertazzoni: 24-inch gas range / sink: Wayfair: Ventana 15-inch stone bar prep sink by Native Trails / countertops: white carrara marble / backsplash tile: Express Brooklyn Tile: beveled white subway tile

Bathroom selects >> floor tile: Express Brooklyn Tile / toilet: Toto: Drake / faucet and showerhead: Wayfair: Arzo by Delta / wall tile: Express Brooklyn Tilebeveled white subway tile

Sweeten handpicks the best general contractors to match each project’s location, budget, scope, and style. Follow the blog for renovation ideas and inspiration and when you’re ready to renovate, start your renovation on Sweeten.

  • rsa

    Beautiful apartment!

  • Julie Durand

    who makes the kitchen faucet please? the detail at the end of the faucet head looks great.

  • Jeff Finn

    Yeh… the faucet piqued my interest as well, any info on it?

    edit: Ok… , found it – it’s the Gramercy faucet by Vigo


    Love this! Gorgeous and clever, and the apartment now looks so much bigger and brighter. We have a similarly small bathroom and would love the details on the clever vanity and sink combo, especially the sink. What make and style is it please? We have been looking at the shallow vanities at Ikea but their sinks are more angular and not comfortable for face washing. This all looks really great, comfortable and practical.

  • Pingback: Why Galley Kitchens Rule in Small Spaces()

  • Deborah Lauren

    Drool worthy. Love it!!!!