Five Boroughs, 10 Fixer-Uppers on the Market

by Kelley Rowland

Reno-ready properties brimming with potential

In New York City’s always competitive real estate market, fixer-uppers are the answer to finding the right location or space at the right price. As evidenced by our before-and-after “reveals” every week, an apartment or home can reach its potential with a little TLC and a first-rate general contractor. We’re obsessed with scouting on-the-market properties from NYC’s real estate marketplace StreetEasy; here, a few to start your hunt for the perfect fixer-upper.

Manhattan

living room and floor planThis Yorkville studio boasts south-facing windows and is in the back of the building away from street noise—a win-win! Plus, the open floor plan leaves plenty of opportunity to create a layout that works for your lifestyle.

Price: $299,000

living room and floor planYou had us at five large closets. This one-bedroom in Lenox Hill leaves nothing to be desired thanks to its in-unit laundry, building amenities (roof-deck, garage), and storage options. Parquet floors and white walls expand the unit, giving plenty of room for an imaginative owner to add their personal touch.

Price: $649,000

Queens

A doorman building with views of the Manhattan skyline and the Brooklyn and Kosciuszko bridges? We’re sold. This Woodside, Queens one-bedroom has plenty of charm and space to spare and has great bones for an owner looking to renovate.

Price: $339,000

living space and exterior Just two blocks away from the Long Island Railroad, this four-family home in Bayside, Queens, has a prime location and is in good condition, but the kitchens and bathrooms are dated. Best of all? There’s hardwood throughout.

Price: $1,580,000

Brooklyn

Townhome enthusiasts, this one’s for you. The four-story, two-unit residence in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, has no shortage of original character—those doors!—and is definitely ready to be restored to its former glory.

Price: $1,299,000

Sure the ceilings and floors are impressive, but this building also boasts updated mechanicals and a new roof—which means a future owner can focus on interior renovations. The three-family home in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, can be reconfigured to create a rental unit, too.

Price: $1,375,000

Staten Island

dining room and exteriorThe best way to describe this Huguenot, Staten Island, single-family home? Potential, space, and location. From the charming sunroom that overlooks the deck and yard to the spacious living areas, it’s a house made for entertaining.

Price: $899,888

kitchen and exterior This Eltingville, Staten Island, home provides the best of suburban living but is also close to shopping, dining, and transportation amenities. There are four bedrooms and a semi-finished basement, plus zoning that allows for adding buildable square footage, making it a great option for a growing family.

Price: $519,000

The Bronx

living room and exteriorThe current owners have lived in this Morris Park, Bronx home for 80 years. The fixer-upper needs some TLC, but has a great base with three bedrooms, an unfinished basement, and a fully-enclosed front porch.

Price: $469,000

If you’re looking for a gut-worthy renovation, here you have it. At 1,800 square feet this Mott Haven, Bronx abode will give all the space you need, both inside and out. Bring a contractor and your imagination!

Price: $550,000

Note: All prices are captured upon the publication of this article.

Here’s how to line up your renovation with your fixer-upper purchase.

Sweeten handpicks the best general contractors to match each project’s location, budget, and scope, helping until project completion. Follow the blog, Sweeten Stories, for renovation ideas and inspiration and when you’re ready to renovate, start your renovation on Sweeten.

Explore other stories